By Don Heckman
The jazz Grammys have been awarded and – Surprise! – there are no surprises. Which, given the nominations, is not particularly surprising.
Even so, that’s not to question the worthiness of winners such as the Joe Zawinul album 75, (recorded a couple of months before the composer/keyboardist’s death) – despite its peculiar presence in the “Best Contemporary Jazz Album” category. Kurt Elling’s award in the “Best Jazz Vocal Album” was richly deserved; it was his ninth nomination and first win. So, too, for the Bebo and Chucho Valdes award for “Best Latin Jazz Album.” The father and son Cuban piano stars have been instrumental in bringing first rate Cuban jazz to wide audiences. And as an addendum in other categories, it was good to see pianist Bill Cunliffe receive a “Best Instrumental Arrangement Award” for West Side Story Medley (Resonance), and Claus Ogerman win the “Best Instrumental Arrangement Accompanying Vocalists” for Diana Krall’s Quiet Nights (Verve).
It was, on the other hand, unfortunate to see younger talent – Julian Lage, Gerald Clayton, Miguel Zenon – overlooked. But they’ll have plenty of opportunities in the future.
The real problems lay, as they have for the past few years, in the nominations and the definitions for the categories. Too often – the “Best Jazz Vocal Album” category was a good example – fine recordings from lesser known talent were ignored in favor of familiar faces. Other categories – “Best Contemporary Album,” “Best Latin Jazz Album,” ”Best Large Jazz Ensemble Album” – are catch-alls, pitting dissimilar nominees against each other, reflecting the Recording Academy’s seemingly diminishing knowledge and interest in jazz. And the “Best Improvised Solo” category continues to be an absurd grouping. One wonders what definitions a voting member uses to compare, say, an improvised solo by Martial Solal to a solo by Terence Blanchard.
Getting back to the “Surprise” (or lack of same) factor, it wasn’t surprising that the jazz awards were given in the afternoon, relegated to the non-televised segment of the Awards. But it was startling to see the Grammys handed out by pop singer/songwriter Colbie Cailiat and Fleetwood Mac’s Mick Fleetwood. It wasn’t clear what, exactly, their connection with jazz might have been. Maybe the Academy knows something I don’t.
Here are the nominations and the winners:
Best Contemporary Jazz Album
WINNER: Joe Zawinul & The Zawinul Syndicate 75 (Heads Up International)
Stefon Harris & Blackout Urbanus (Concord Jazz)
Julian Lage Sounding Point (Emarcy/Decca)
Philippe Saisse At World’s Edge (E1 Music)
Mike Stern Big Neighborhood (Heads Up International)
……………………………………..
Best Jazz Vocal Album
WINNER: Kurt Elling Dedicated To You: Kurt Elling Sings The Music Of Coltrane and Hartman (Concord)
Randy Crawford No Regrets (PRA Records)
Roberta Gambarini So In Love (Groovin’ High/Emarcy)
Luciana Souza Tide (Verve)
Tierney Sutton Desire (Telarc Jazz)
………………………………………
Best Improvised Jazz Solo
WINNER: Terence Blanchard “Dancin’ 4 Chicken” from Jeff ‘Tain” Watts CD, Watts (Dark Key Music)
Gerald Clayton “All Of You” (ArtistShare)
Roy Hargrove “Ms. Garvey, Ms. Garvey” (Groovin’ High/Emarcy)
Martial Solal “On Green Dolphin Street” (CamJazz)
Miguel Zenon “Villa Palmeras” (Marsalis Music)
……………………………………………………………………………………..
Best Jazz Instrumental Album, Individual Or Group
WINNER: Chick Corea & John McLaughlin Five Peace Band Five Peace Band – Live (Concord Records)
Gary Burton, Pat Metheny, Steve Swallow & Antonio Sanchez Quartet Live (Concord Jazz)
Clayton Brothers Brother To Brother (ArtistShare)
John Patitucci Trio Remembrance (Concord Jazz)
Allen Toussaint The Bright Mississippi (Nonesuch)
…………………………………………………………………………………………..
Best Large Jazz Ensemble Album
WINNER: New Orleans Jazz Orchestra Book One (World Village
Bob Florence Limited Edition Legendary (MAMA Records)
John Hollenbeck Large Ensemble Eternal Interlude (Sunnyside)
Sammy Nestico And The SWR Big Band Fun Time (Hanssler Classic)
University Of North Texas One O’Clock Lab Band Lab 2009 (North Texas Jazz)
………………………………………………………………………………………..
Best Latin Jazz Album (Vocal or Instrumental)
WINNER: Bebo Valdés And Chucho Valdés Juntos Para Siempre (Sony Music/Calle 54)
Chembo Corniel Things I Wanted To Do (Chemboro Records)
Geoffrey Keezer Aurea (ArtistShare)
Claudio Roditi Brazilliance X 4 (Resonance Records)
Miguel Zenón Esta Plena (Marsalis Music)
Posted by irom 





















